As the year comes to a close, analysts at Consumer Reports take a critical look at the diverse array of vehicles tested at their expansive Auto Test Center. While many cars shine, showcasing commendable performance, others tend to leave a disappointing impression. This year, a few standouts captured the testers’ frustrations from the onset.
In a recent episode of “Talking Cars,” the team was posed an intriguing question: What model left the worst impression this year? The responses revealed a variety of vehicles that raised eyebrows for different reasons. Among them were the polarizing Tesla Cybertruck, a selection of underwhelming Volvo EVs, and the latest iteration of the Toyota 4Runner, which failed to impress as its predecessor did.
Tesla Cybertruck
Despite its media buzz and striking design, the Tesla Cybertruck struggled to earn affection within Consumer Reports. Frustrations were voiced regarding the steering and parking, particularly in tight spaces. Clumsy handling at low speeds and awkward steering highlighted hesitations regarding daily usability, suggesting that despite its notoriety, the vehicle fell short in practical application.
Toyota 4Runner
The redesigned Toyota 4Runner was one of the most awaited vehicles heading into 2025, but it disappointed many among the testing team. Although it wasn’t outright terrible, it missed the mark regarding expectations. Complaints included engine noise, vibration, and an uncomfortable ride, signaling stagnation rather than progress.
Volvo EX30
Volvo’s EX30 compact EV faced strong backlash among testers who unanimously agreed it was lacking. Criticism focused on its poor interface and an overly complicated system. Although praised for its acceleration, the excessive reliance on technology overshadowed what could have been a strong new entry. It sparked a rare collective disappointment among testers.